Musical Context of Edward Said’s Contrapuntal Reading

Authors

  • Svitlana Macenka Ivan Franko National University of Lviv, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31861/pytlit2018.97.085

Keywords:

the interaction of literature and music, the principle of crossing boundaries, method of contrapuntal reading, contrapuntal understanding, E. Said, T. Mann, G. Gould

Abstract

The aim of article is to expand the theoretical problematic field of “music in literature” with the ideas of American literary critic, culture critic, music critic and musician Edward Said. These elaborations are part of literary criticism comparative studies and intermediality. Thus, we are discussing the method of contrapuntal reading developed by Edward Said on the basis of reception of music and referencing the creativity of famous composers and musicians. An important principle of crossing boundaries has been singled out, by which the thinker implies the ability music and literature to adapt mutually to each other, to contain and add social structures and change means of expression depending on situations and public, power and sex constellations. It is also noted that for a literary critic it is absolutely natural to provide arguments as to certain poetological aspects of a literary work resorting to regularities of musical art and, vice versa, efficiently employ literary context when discussing musical pieces. Edward Said contributed to change of the perception of opera, which in his interpretation turned into a place of social discourse. It is stressed that contrapuntal reading is characterized, first of all, by a link between an aesthetic concept and a powerful political definition of the direction “contra”, and secondly, by a combination of different forms of art and activity in a single general concept which claims to be metaphoric and methodological at the same time. Separate essays by Edward Said in which he interprets the role of counterpoint have been analyzed, in particular those referring to the creativity of G. Gould. The analysis is based on Edward Said’s essays about music published in Musical Elaborations, 1991 and Music at The Limits, 2007.

Author Biography

Svitlana Macenka, Ivan Franko National University of Lviv

German philology department

Ivan Franko National University of Lviv

1, Universytetska St., 79000, Lviv, Ukraine

References

Bakhtin M. Problemy tvorchestva Dostoevskogo. Problemy poetiki Dostoevskogo [Problems of Dostoevsky’s Art. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics].Kyiv, 1994, 511 p. (in Russian).

Énard M. Kompas [Compass]. Lviv, 2017, 487 p. (in Ukrainian).

Mann Th. Doktor Faustus [Doctor Faustus]. Kharkiv, 2011, 575 p. (in Ukrainian).

Said E. Kultura y Imperializm [Culture and Imperialism]. Kyiv, 2007, 608 p. (in Ukrainian).

Said E. Oriientalizm [Orientalism]. Kyiv, 2001, 511 p. (in Ukrainian).

Adorno Th. W. Die Funktion des Kontrapunkts in der neuen Musik [1957]. In: Musikalische Schriften. Frankfurt am Main, 1978, S. 144–168.

Dunkler A. Kontrapunktische Lektüren. Koloniale Strukturen in der deutschsprachigen Literatur des 19. Jahrhunderts. Paderborn, 2009, 193 S.

Honold A. Kontrapunkt. Zur Geschichte musikalischer und literarischer Stimmung bis in die Gegenwart. In: Gess N., Honold A. Handbuch Literatur & Musik. Berlin, 2017, S. 508–534.

Honold A. The Art of counter point. Music as Site and Tool in Postcolonial Readings. In: Edward Saidʼs Translocations. Essays in Sealer Criticism. Ney York, London, 2012, pp. 187–204.

Kreutzinger-Herr A. Oper als Imperialismus und Giuseppe Verdis Aida. In: Herr C., Woitas M. Musik mit Methode: neue kulturwissenschaftliche Perspektiven. Köln, Weimar, 2006, S. 177–196.

Polyphonie, Intertextualität und Intermedialität. Ein interdisziplinäres Forschungsfeld. Aachen, 2010, 184 S.

Previšić B. Autorität und Autor, Kanon und kontrapunktische Polyphonie. Literaturtheorie in musikalischer Verschärfung. Autorität und Moderne. Colloquium Helveticum 41, 2010, S. 187–202.

Said Edward W. Musik ohne Grenze. Mit einem Vorwort von Daniel Barenboim. München, 2012, 412 S.

Said Edward W. Der Wohltemperierte Satz. Musik, Interpretation und Kritik. München, Wien, 1995, 150 S.

Schlößler F. Literaturwissenschaft als Kulturwissenschaft. Tübingen und Basel, 2006. – 274 S.

Published

2018-06-29

How to Cite

Macenka, S. “Musical Context of Edward Said’s Contrapuntal Reading”. Pitannâ lìteraturoznavstva, no. 97, June 2018, pp. 85-103, doi:10.31861/pytlit2018.97.085.

Issue

Section

Intertextuality and Intermediality