Universal Notions in Culture and Methodology of Traditionalism

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31861/pytlit2022.105.137

Keywords:

integral traditionalism, mythology, metaphysics, René Guénon, Mircea Eliade

Abstract

The article examines the methodology of integral traditionalism as a tool for the analysis of myth, art, literature and the identification of universal metaphysical foundations of culture. René Guénon’s teaching is considered as one of methods of literary criticism that goes beyond philology itself. The methodological approaches of traditionalism, whiche were ahead of the structuralist turn in the humanities, allow to enrich the field of literary studies as well. The article points out its advantages and disadvantages, and compares the traditionalists’ approach with the more measured method of Mircea Eliade and his view of “mystical” and “esoteric” creativity in literature. According to traditionalism, some literary texts should be read primarily as works of a metaphysical and occult nature. This means that a purely philological approach to their analysis may be counterproductive. Traditionalists propose to go beyond literary studies and connect it not only with philosophy and religious studies, but also with theology and metaphysics. In this study, we show how René Guenon and his students interpreted the texts of Dante Alighieri, Victor Hugo, Gustav Meyrink, Hermann Hesse and others from the perspective of esotericism. At the same time, we show the limitations of this approach in the analysis of poetry and works of mass literature, where authors are guided by fashion or pure sensual inspiration.

Author Biography

Sviatoslav Vyshynskyi, H. Skovoroda Institute of Philosophy Institute of Philosophy of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine

Department of philosophical anthropology

H. Skovoroda Institute of Philosophy Institute of Philosophy of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine

4 Trokhsvyatytelska Street, 01001, Kyiv, Ukraine

References

Guénon, R. (2003a). Tsarstvo kolichestva i znameniia vremeni [The Reign of Quantity and the Signs of the Times]. In: Guénon, R. Tsarstvo kolichestva i znameniia vremeni. Ocherki ob induizme. Ezoterizm Dante. Translated from the French by T. Lubimova. Moscow : Belovod'e, pp. 7–302. (in Russian).

Guénon, R. (2003b). Ezoterizm Dante [The Esoterism of Dante]. In: Guénon, R. Tsarstvo kolichestva i znameniia vremeni. Ocherki ob induizme. Ezoterizm Dante. Translated from the French by T. Lubimova. Moscow : Belovod'e, pp. 407–468. (in Russian).

Guénon, R. (2004a). Vostochnaia metafizika [Oriental Metaphysics]. In: Guénon, R. Chelovek i ego osushchestvlenie soglasno Vedante. Vostochnaia metafizika. Translated from the French by N. Tiros. Moscow : Belovod'e, pp. 225–249. (in Russian).

Guénon, R. (2004b). Simvoly sviashchennoi nauki [Symbols of Sacred Science]. Translated from the French by N. Tiros. Moscow : Belovod'e, 480 p. (in Russian).

Guénon, R. (2008). Krizis sovremennogo mira [The Crisis of the Modern World]. Translated from the French by N. Melentyeva and oth. Moscow : Eksmo, 784 p. (in Russian).

Guénon, R. (2010). Ocherki o traditsii i metafizike [Studies in Tradition and Metaphysics]. Translated from the French by V. Bystrov. Saint-Petersburg : Azbuka-klassika, 320 p. (in Russian).

Golovin, E. (2007). Eto ubyet to [This kills that]. In: Burckhardt, T. and Hugo, V. Alkhimia i Notre-Dame de Paris. Moscow : Enneagon Press, pp. 335–363. (in Russian).

Zoria, E. (2009). Rol' khudozhestvennoi literatury v issledovanii sovremennoi magii [The Role of Literature in the Study of Contemporary Magic]. In: Mistiko-ezotericheskie dvizhenia v teorii i praktike. Istoria. Psikhologia. Filosofia. Proceedings of the 2nd international conference, 2008, Saint-Petersburg. Saint-Petersburg : Russkaia khristianskaia gumanitarnaia akademia, pp. 75–84. (in Russian).

Evola, J. (2005). Osedlat' tigra [Ride the Tiger]. Translated from the Italian by V. Vaniushkina. Saint-Petersburg : Vladimir Dal', 512 p. (in Russian).

Eliade, M. (2008). Zhatva solntsevorota (1937–1960) [The Solstice Harvest (1937–1960)]. In: Eliade, M. Posuly ravnodenstvia. Memuary (1907–1937). Zhatva solntsevorota. Memuary (1937–1960). Translated from the Romanian by A. Starostina. Moscow : Kriterion, pp. 281–432. (in Russian).

Ellwood, R. (1999). The politics of myth: a study of C.G. Jung, Mircea Eliade, and Joseph Campbell. Albany : State University of New York Press, 211 p.

Quinn, W. (1997). The only Tradition. Albany : State University of New York Press, 390 p.

Published

2022-10-28

How to Cite

Vyshynskyi, S. “Universal Notions in Culture and Methodology of Traditionalism”. Pitannâ lìteraturoznavstva, no. 105, Oct. 2022, pp. 137-46, doi:10.31861/pytlit2022.105.137.

Issue

Section

Methodology